Opinion

Why is Brazil’s lower house impervious to public opinion?

Pro-environment groups occupied Brazil’s Congress last week to protest against the approval of a set of bills known as the “destruction package,” including proposals to loosen rules on pesticide use and mining, among other changes. On Wednesday, protesters were joined by famous Brazilian songwriter Caetano Veloso for a rally against a bill legalizing mining activities on protected indigenous lands. However, despite this high-profile pressure, the House went ahead and fast-tracked the bill regardless, meaning it will go to a vote between April 12 and 14, without having to undergo analysis from a series of legislative committees.

In light of this decision, one must ask why Brazil’s lower house has been so impervious to public opinion. Are its members of Congress simply not fussed about voters’ opinions? Even in an election year? 

While the “secret budget” has acted as a cushion protecting lawmakers against unpopular decisions, analysts have overlooked another explanation for this phenomenon. The agribusiness caucus has been a key driving force behind the so-called “destruction package,” which, under House Speaker Arthur Lira, has only become more powerful and influential. 

Pro-environment groups seek to stop the approval of the following bills: PL 3729/2004, which weakens restrictions on economic activities that can be carried out on protected...

Beatriz Rey

Beatriz Rey is an SNF Agora Visiting Fellow at Johns Hopkins University and an APSA Congressional Fellow (2021-2022). She holds a Ph.D. in political science from Syracuse University and an M.A. in political science from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

Recent Posts

Explaining Brazil #291: Lula’s farming feuds

The relationship between farmers and the Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva administration is by no…

4 hours ago

The legacy of Ayrton Senna, 30 years on

Pelé, Ronaldo, Zico, Marta … All of Brazil’s truly immortal sporting icons are footballers, that…

4 hours ago

Brazil and Paraguay deadlocked over Itaipu dam

Speaking before a Senate hearing on Tuesday, Chief of Staff Rui Costa admitted that Brazil…

17 hours ago

Brazil’s job market remains strong despite unemployment uptick

New job market data from the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE) show the…

19 hours ago

Brazil wants to know more about its domestic workers

Brazil officially had 5.83 million domestic workers in 2022 — almost the entire population of…

1 day ago

Brazil’s latest Covid vaccine purchase comes too late

Brazil’s Ministry of Health this month announced a purchase of 12.5 million doses of Moderna’s…

2 days ago